A truck of saria reaches the site. The contractor sends it to the nearest dharam kanta, and the slip shows 180 kg less than your bill. Now there is a phone call, an argument, and a payment on hold. A weighbridge weight difference is one of the most common disputes in the steel and sand trade, and most of them can be avoided with clear billing rules and good records.
This guide explains why weights differ, what tolerance the Indian standard allows for TMT bars, how to check a kanta slip, and a simple step-by-step process to settle a dispute without losing the customer.
Why the bill weight and kanta weight are rarely the same
There are three different "weights" in a steel deal, and people often mix them up:
- Theoretical (sectional) weight. Calculated from the bar size using the standard formula: kg per metre = d²/162, where d is the diameter in mm. A 12 mm bar is 0.888 kg/m, so a 12 m bar is about 10.66 kg.
- Actual weight. What the bars really weigh. Rolling mills produce bars slightly heavier or lighter than nominal, within a tolerance.
- Weighbridge weight. What a particular kanta says on a particular day: gross weight of the loaded truck minus the tare (empty) weight.
Each one can be correct and still disagree with the others. The bill should say clearly which basis was used.
For sand and gitti, there is a fourth problem: the material is often sold by volume (brass or CFT) but the customer checks it by weight. Moisture, compaction and loading style all change the weight of the same volume, so a volume sale should never be "checked" only on a weighbridge.
Theoretical vs actual weight: what IS 1786 allows
IS 1786 (the BIS standard for high strength deformed steel bars) sets nominal mass per metre and a tolerance band. Unless the manufacturer and buyer agree otherwise, the tolerance on nominal mass is:
| Nominal bar size | Tolerance for a batch | Tolerance for an individual sample |
|---|---|---|
| Up to and including 10 mm | ±7% | −8% |
| Over 10 mm up to 16 mm | ±5% | −6% |
| Over 16 mm | ±3% | −4% |
The standard also says there is no plus limit for an individual sample, so a single heavier bar is not a defect.
What this means in practice: a batch of 12 mm bars can weigh up to 5% less or more than the theoretical weight and still meet the standard. If you bill on theoretical weight and the customer weighs the truck, a few percent difference is normal and not "chori".
Two practical rules follow:
- Decide the basis before the sale. Either bill on actual weight (kanta weight) or on theoretical weight per bar, and print it on the quotation and bill.
- Never mix bases in one deal. Buying from the supplier on actual weight and selling to the customer on theoretical weight (or the reverse) leaves you carrying the difference.
Our sariya rate and billing guide explains how dealers quote per kg and per piece.
Worked example: a 12 mm truck load
A customer orders about 10 tonnes of 12 mm TMT. You load 940 bars.
Theoretical weight on your bill - 0.888 kg/m × 12 m = 10.656 kg per bar - 940 bars × 10.656 kg = 10,016.6 kg, about 10.02 tonnes
Customer's dharam kanta slip - Gross weight (loaded truck): 25,480 kg - Tare weight (empty truck): 15,320 kg - Net weight: 10,160 kg
Difference: 10,160 − 10,016.6 = 143.4 kg, which is about 1.4% more than the theoretical weight.
In this example the customer is actually receiving more steel than billed, which is within the ±5% batch tolerance for 12 mm bars. If the slip had shown 9,880 kg (about 1.4% less), that would also be inside tolerance, but the customer would see a "shortage".
This is why the agreement matters. With a theoretical-weight deal, the bill stands either way. With an actual-weight deal, you would bill the kanta weight from a slip both sides accept.
All numbers above are for illustration only.
How to read and check a dharam kanta slip
Before you accept or reject any weighbridge weight difference, look closely at the slip:
- Weighbridge name, address and slip number. An unnamed slip is weak evidence.
- Vehicle number. It must match the truck on your challan.
- Date and time of both weighings. Gross and tare should be close in time. A tare taken days earlier, or taken from an old record, can be wrong if fuel, spare tyre, tarpaulin or crew changed.
- Gross, tare and net. Check that net = gross − tare. Simple arithmetic errors do happen.
- Material and party name. It should match the delivery.
Weighbridges used in trade come under the Legal Metrology Act and its rules. They must be verified and stamped by the state Legal Metrology department, and are normally re-verified at regular intervals (commonly yearly). If you doubt a weighbridge, it is fair to ask whether its verification certificate is current. Rules and inspection schedules are enforced by states, so check with your local Legal Metrology office if a dispute becomes serious.
Record the kanta slip number on the bill
The single best habit is to write weighbridge details on your own documents:
- On the delivery challan: vehicle number, kanta name, slip number, gross, tare and net.
- On the tax invoice: the billing basis ("billed on actual weight as per kanta slip no. ___" or "billed on theoretical weight, 12 m bars").
- For purchases: the supplier's mill weight, your own kanta weight on arrival, and the difference.
Keep the slip photo with the bill. When a customer calls three weeks later, you can answer in one minute. A delivery challan that carries vehicle, site and freight details, shared on WhatsApp with the slip photo, gives both sides the same record. In MaterialBill you can add these details to the challan and invoice so they print on the bill itself.
Settling a weighbridge weight difference in steel
When a customer reports a shortage, follow the same steps every time:
- Ask for the slip. No slip, no discussion on numbers.
- Check the basis. Was the deal on theoretical or actual weight? If theoretical, explain IS 1786 tolerance politely and show the bar count.
- Count the bars. For theoretical deals, piece count is what matters. Ask the customer to count bundles and loose bars at site.
- Compare both slips. Your loading slip (if you weighed at dispatch) and the customer's slip. If tare weights differ a lot, that is usually the cause.
- Re-weigh if needed. If the amount is large, agree on a third weighbridge with a valid verification and both sides present.
- Settle in writing. If you give a credit, issue a proper credit note against the invoice instead of a verbal adjustment.
For repeat contractors, put the weight basis and the tolerance you accept into your terms once, so you do not argue on every load.
Sand and gitti: volume sales and weight checks
For sand and aggregate, the cleanest approach is to sell on one basis and measure on that same basis:
- Selling by brass or CFT: measure the loaded body length × width × height at your yard and write the measurement on the challan. 1 brass = 100 CFT.
- Selling by tonne: weigh at a stamped weighbridge and attach the slip number to the bill.
Wet sand weighs more than dry sand of the same volume, so a customer who buys by brass and checks by weight will see different numbers on different days. Explain this upfront. A billing setup for sand suppliers that supports both brass and tonne helps here, and transport and freight costing covers the cost side.
Frequently asked questions
How much weighbridge weight difference is normal for TMT bars?
Under IS 1786, a batch can vary from nominal mass by ±7% for bars up to 10 mm, ±5% for over 10 mm up to 16 mm, and ±3% above 16 mm. A small difference inside this band is normal.
Should I bill steel on theoretical weight or actual weight?
Either is acceptable if both sides agree before the sale. Print the basis on the quotation and invoice, and buy and sell on the same basis so you do not absorb the difference.
What should a dharam kanta slip show?
The weighbridge name, slip number, vehicle number, date and time, gross weight, tare weight, net weight, and ideally material and party name. Check that net equals gross minus tare.
Can I ask for a weighbridge's verification certificate?
Yes. Weighbridges used in trade must be verified and stamped under Legal Metrology rules. If you doubt a reading, asking for the current verification is reasonable.
How do I adjust a genuine shortage on a GST bill?
Issue a credit note against the original invoice for the agreed quantity and value, rather than reducing the next bill informally. Your CA can confirm the GST treatment.
Weight disputes become simple when every bill carries its weight basis and kanta slip details. If you run a saria and steel shop, you can start free with MaterialBill and bill by kg, quintal or piece with the slip number printed on the challan.