In most building material markets, the mistri, plumber, electrician or thekedar decides where a homeowner buys. That is why many dealers pay a mistri commission for referrals. Done openly and recorded properly, it is a normal business expense. Done casually, from the cash drawer with no record, it quietly eats your margin and creates tax and trust problems later.
This guide explains how to set up a fair referral scheme, track commission party-wise, keep it visible in your profit, and understand the TDS position under the new Income-tax Act from FY 2026-27.
Why mistri commission needs a system
Ask any hardware or sanitary dealer and you will hear the same problems:
- Nobody knows the total. Commission is paid in small amounts across the month. At year end, the owner cannot say how much was paid or to whom.
- Margin disappears on certain sales. A 4% referral on an item where your margin is 6% leaves very little after freight and credit cost.
- Double claims. Two mistris claim the same customer, or the same bill is claimed twice.
- Customer distrust. If the homeowner learns that the rate was inflated to fund a hidden commission, you lose the customer and your name in the colony.
- Tax exposure. Large unrecorded payments cannot be claimed as expenses properly, and TDS may apply above a limit.
A simple system solves all five.
Keep it legitimate and transparent
A referral commission is legitimate when it is a payment for genuinely bringing business, paid by you from your margin, at a rate you have decided, and recorded in your books. A few ground rules:
- Do not inflate the customer's price to fund the commission without the customer knowing. Charge your normal party rate.
- Pay the person who referred, not the customer's employee behind their back, where the customer would object. If a builder's site supervisor is asking you for a cut on the builder's purchases, that is a different situation, and many dealers refuse it.
- Write your scheme down. One page: who is eligible, rate or fixed amount per category, when it is paid, and what happens on returns and unpaid bills.
- Pay by bank transfer or UPI where possible, so there is a clear trail.
Some dealers run "loyalty points" or gift schemes for plumbers and electricians instead of cash commission. The same tracking rules apply.
Choose a commission structure that protects margin
There are three common structures. Pick based on your margins, not on what the shop next door does.
| Structure | How it works | Good for | Watch out for |
|---|---|---|---|
| Percentage of bill | Fixed % of taxable value of referred bills | Sanitary, paint, electrical where margins are known | Paying % on low-margin items like cement |
| Fixed per unit | ₹ per bag, per box, per tonne | Cement, tiles, steel | Fixing it too high when rates fall |
| Slab by category | Different % for each category | Mixed hardware shops | More complex to explain |
Rule of thumb: set commission as a share of your gross margin on that category, not as a share of the bill. If your margin on an item is small, a percentage of the bill can wipe it out.
Worked example: what commission really costs
Here is an illustrative example with made-up numbers. A plumber refers a homeowner who buys sanitary items and pipes worth ₹80,000 (taxable value). Your average gross margin on this mix is 15%.
| Line | Amount |
|---|---|
| Taxable value of referred sale | ₹80,000 |
| Gross margin at 15% | ₹12,000 |
| Commission at 3% of bill | ₹2,400 |
| Delivery cost for this order | ₹800 |
| Margin left after commission and delivery | ₹8,800 |
| Effective margin | 11% |
Now take the same 3% on ₹80,000 of cement and steel, where suppose your margin is only 4% (₹3,200). After ₹2,400 commission and ₹800 delivery, you are left with nothing. This is why commission should be category-wise. Our guide on how to calculate profit margin shows how to work out real margin per category.
How to track commission party-wise
The goal: for every referral partner, you can see referred bills, commission earned, commission paid and balance, at any time.
1. Create each mistri or contractor as a party. Name, phone, trade (plumber, electrician, mason, thekedar), area, and PAN if you will pay them a significant amount in a year.
2. Tag the referrer on the bill. At billing, note who referred the customer. Do it on the bill, not in a separate notebook.
3. Calculate commission only on paid bills. Many dealers pay commission only after the customer pays. This protects you when a referred customer goes into long udhaar. If you run credit, your udhaar management should show which referred bills are still pending.
4. Adjust for returns. If goods come back, reduce the commission on that bill.
5. Pay on a fixed cycle. Weekly or monthly, with a statement. Record each payment in your cash or bank book against the partner's account.
6. Send a statement before paying. A short party statement listing bills, commission and payments avoids arguments. A party statement shared on WhatsApp works well.
In MaterialBill you can keep each mistri or thekedar as a separate party, record payments in the cash book and pull a party statement whenever they ask "mera kitna bana?".
Thekedar accounts: when the contractor is also the buyer
Many contractors are both your customer and your referrer. They buy material for their sites on credit and also expect something for the business they bring. Keep these separate:
- Purchase account: their bills, payments and udhaar balance.
- Commission or discount: decide whether it is a discount on their own bills (shown on the invoice) or a separate referral payment.
If it is a discount on their own purchases, show it on the invoice before tax, so GST is charged on the discounted value. If it is a referral payment for other customers' purchases, record it as an expense. Mixing the two makes the khata confusing and the tax treatment unclear; ask your CA which fits your arrangement.
The tax angle: TDS on commission from FY 2026-27
From 1 April 2026, the Income-tax Act, 2025 replaced the Income-tax Act, 1961. TDS on commission and brokerage, earlier under Section 194H, now sits in the TDS table under Section 393(1) of the new Act. As per the Income Tax Department's listing of Section 393:
- Rate: 2% on commission (other than insurance commission) or brokerage paid to a resident.
- Threshold: no TDS if the total commission paid or credited to that person in the tax year does not exceed ₹20,000.
- Who must deduct: a "specified person". This covers firms and companies, and individuals or HUFs whose business turnover exceeded ₹1 crore (or professional receipts exceeded ₹50 lakh) in the preceding tax year.
- No PAN: a higher rate applies if the payee does not give a PAN, so collect PAN from regular partners.
So if your shop is a firm or company, or you are an individual whose turnover crossed ₹1 crore last year, and you pay one mistri more than ₹20,000 in commission in a year, TDS likely applies, along with deposit and TDS return filing. Separate rules can apply to high-value payments by individuals who are not specified persons. Tax rules change and the new Act is still settling in, so confirm the position for your business with your CA.
Frequently asked questions
Is paying mistri commission legal?
Paying a referral commission from your own margin, at a disclosed rate, recorded in your books, is a normal business practice. Problems arise when it is hidden from the buyer, funded by inflated rates, or paid without records.
What is the TDS rate on commission in FY 2026-27?
Under Section 393(1) of the Income-tax Act, 2025, TDS on commission or brokerage is 2%, when total commission to one resident exceeds ₹20,000 in the tax year and the payer is a specified person. Confirm with your CA.
Should commission be paid before or after the customer pays?
Many dealers pay only after the referred bill is paid. This avoids paying commission on sales that turn into bad debt.
How do I stop two mistris claiming the same customer?
Tag the referrer on the bill at the time of sale, and announce that only the name on the bill gets commission. Disputes after billing are then easy to settle.
Should I give contractors a discount or a commission?
On their own purchases, a discount shown on the invoice is cleaner. For other customers they refer, a separate referral commission is clearer. Keep the two in separate records.
Commission is a cost of getting business, and like any cost it should be visible. If you run a hardware shop, you can start free with MaterialBill and keep referral partners, payments and statements in one place.